Some moments in music history are so ironic that they become legendary, and Smokey Robinson had one of those moments when a fan asked him why he was singing a Michael Jackson song.
During an interview with DJ Vlad, Smokey Robinson was talking about his iconic song “Who’s Lovin’ You”, a classic written by him in 1960 for his group, The Miracles. The song was later covered by The Jackson 5, with a young Michael Jackson delivering one of his most soulful and emotional performances at just 10 years old.
Michael’s version was so powerful and widely recognized that many people today assume it was originally his. That’s exactly what led to this hilarious moment for Smokey.
The Fan Who Didn’t Know
Smokey shared that he once had a fan approach him and ask:
“Why are you singing Michael Jackson’s song?”
Smokey could only laugh because, well—he wrote it. The irony of being questioned about his own song wasn’t lost on him.
This moment is a testament to how legendary Michael Jackson was—he had such an impact on songs he covered that people thought they were his. But it’s also a reminder that behind many great hits, there’s a songwriting genius like Smokey Robinson, whose pen shaped the sound of Motown and beyond.
The Legacy of “Who’s Lovin’ You”
Even though The Miracles originally recorded the song, it was The Jackson 5’s version that introduced it to a global audience. Michael’s youthful, raw emotion gave the song a new life, making it one of the standout performances of his early career.
But the fact remains—Smokey Robinson is the mastermind behind it.
So next time you hear “Who’s Lovin’ You,” remember: Smokey wrote it, and he can sing it whenever he wants.
